This is actually a pretty darn good list. I can’t disagree with too much. My top 10 is: 1 – Babe Ruth 2 – Willie Mays 3 – Ty Cobb 4 – Walter Johnson 5 – Barry Bonds 6 – Hank Aaron 7 – Ted Williams 8 – Josh Gibson 9 – Lou Gehrig 10 – Lefty Grove
I'm really ok with this list and your reasoning behind it with one exception. Bonds cheated and does not deserve to even be remembered. Maybe erase him, move the rest up and put Ken Griffey jr or Mike Trout or Big Pappi in at the ten spot…………. nice to see the great Ty Cobb still being given his due respect.
Where is Rogers Hornsby, really this guy's numbers are off the charts, I can think of two guys on this chart who shouldn't even be on the chart, Musial, and Gehrig, and Henry Aaron is and should always be 1 on these lists. And finally, Babe Ruth was just a fat gut with power, who could also hit for average, he is not the greatest baseball player of all time. Aaron, and Bonds are better maybe even Mays. And Ty Cobb should be closer to number 1. I also don't think pitchers should be on the list they should have there own list.
Baseball is an all American sport. There are many lengendary players that made this gave exciting for the audiences, but I believe that Jackie Robinson stands alone as breaking the barrier as being the first African American to be indoctrinated into the professional sport of baseball. Awesome game…Grandma's Angel's
1st I want to say that this is a very very hard topic and can be argued over and over. 2nd. R.I.P. HAMMERING HANK!!! You will always be the homerun king in my eyes. Reggie Jackson should have been on this list along with a couple others. But I can't really complain at all. Like I said before, this is a very hard list to make.
When you talk about the greatest players ever, I always think of who would be the best if you could magically put them together next to each other in the same league. If you watch Babe Ruth in some videos on here, you can't say he has a great swing. Honestly, would he be able to hit in todays game? They were great in their era, which was such a lower calibre of play as compared to today. Yes, they paved the way for todays game, todays players have better equipment, better nutrition and training, but if you were able to have that magic baseball game, you'd all pick modern day players. I'm not sure I'd buy the fact that if all those other players grew up in this era they'd be better. Some maybe?
Although caught up in "probable" criminal activities Joe Jackson should make this list… This includes his career being cut short..
Willie mays
Every baseball legend always calls out averages by says “point…”. How Euro is this guy?
This is actually a pretty darn good list. I can’t disagree with too much. My top 10 is:
1 – Babe Ruth
2 – Willie Mays
3 – Ty Cobb
4 – Walter Johnson
5 – Barry Bonds
6 – Hank Aaron
7 – Ted Williams
8 – Josh Gibson
9 – Lou Gehrig
10 – Lefty Grove
ty cobb is arguably #1, no worse than #3. but 8??
I'm really ok with this list and your reasoning behind it with one exception. Bonds cheated and does not deserve to even be remembered. Maybe erase him, move the rest up and put Ken Griffey jr or Mike Trout or Big Pappi in at the ten spot…………. nice to see the great Ty Cobb still being given his due respect.
In other sports there is always an argument about # 1…..but in baseball it's easy. You just say OK, who is # 2 after the Babe.
Bonds is the best hands down most hrs several golden glove awards and most walked player ever
Horrible list.
Where is Rogers Hornsby, really this guy's numbers are off the charts, I can think of two guys on this chart who shouldn't even be on the chart, Musial, and Gehrig, and Henry Aaron is and should always be 1 on these lists. And finally, Babe Ruth was just a fat gut with power, who could also hit for average, he is not the greatest baseball player of all time. Aaron, and Bonds are better maybe even Mays. And Ty Cobb should be closer to number 1. I also don't think pitchers should be on the list they should have there own list.
Bonds used Drugs!
Cobb should be a lot higher, as should Gehrig.
How are the players back then better then today's players! Less competition or something? And Willie May's is my favorite all time the Black babe Ruth
Cobb and Lou are better than mick
Ty Cobb invented modern baseball.
No chance babe Ruth is number one
Garbage list from garbage people.
Ruth fairly easy. This is a solid list.
mike trout, Ichiro suzuki and pete rose are all top 10
Hank Aaron played for Milwaukee braves the to ATLANTA BRAVES!
Salvo porque Babe Ruth quedó primero, esta es una 💩 de lista.👎
ty cobb 3.67 no. 1
Learn to pronounce the names.
Terrible list
I’m pretty sure Aaron judge should be on there
barry bonds is the best of all time no dout
Shit list.
Koufax should be on this list
Where is albert pujols? 🙂
Baseball is an all American sport. There are many lengendary players that made this gave exciting for the audiences, but I believe that Jackie Robinson stands alone as breaking the barrier as being the first African American to be indoctrinated into the professional sport of baseball. Awesome game…Grandma's Angel's
Bru that was only 9
Weird to think that the guys that was pros back in the day couldn’t compete with most minor league teams now
1st I want to say that this is a very very hard topic and can be argued over and over.
2nd. R.I.P. HAMMERING HANK!!! You will always be the homerun king in my eyes.
Reggie Jackson should have been on this list along with a couple others. But I can't really complain at all. Like I said before, this is a very hard list to make.
Good list but griffrey Jr needs some respect . Swap bonds for Jr
Isnt Ichiro 1.
Not in order, Except Barry Bonds. He is number 1, in my opinion.
Bonds
Mantle
Mays
Henderson
Jeter
Clemens
A-Rod
Rose
Ruth
MCGUIRE
When you talk about the greatest players ever, I always think of who would be the best if you could magically put them together next to each other in the same league. If you watch Babe Ruth in some videos on here, you can't say he has a great swing. Honestly, would he be able to hit in todays game? They were great in their era, which was such a lower calibre of play as compared to today. Yes, they paved the way for todays game, todays players have better equipment, better nutrition and training, but if you were able to have that magic baseball game, you'd all pick modern day players. I'm not sure I'd buy the fact that if all those other players grew up in this era they'd be better. Some maybe?
Bonds at 5? He's either #1 or #1. Get my point