Clemente had a “plus arm”??? Name a player with a better arm? First game I ever went to in 1967 iPittsburgh against Atlanta. Clemente threw out a runner at the plate who had tagged on a deep fly to right. As the ball got closer to the catcher the crowd noise kept getting louder and louder. It was amazing!
derek jeter defensive war is not good he is known for mr.october which big papi was to probably the most clutch player is recent memory i say he is a legend
i mean not saying david ortiz or adgar martinez are legendary however if ur going to make the defense argument ted Williams was a terrible defender, same with babe ruth, jimmie foxx and others so does that mean they should be moved to legendary I don't think so but it seems that where your logic might lay
Best player ever was Mickey Mantel. He could run, bat for average, bat for Home Run, decent arm, and decent defense. He could run and stole bases, even playing with his knees wrap around all time.
LET THE DEBATES… BEGIN!!!
Also, remember that I mixed up Ty Cobb and Tris Speaker. Cobb is a GOAT! One more thing, I could have sworn Banks was a 2B .. 😂
How are George Brett and Tony Gwynn on this list but Todd Helton is not?
Some of those legends should be in the “great” category. Beltre, Cabrera, Dawson, Larkin forsure should be in “great”
Put everyone in GoAt territory, yeah that makes sense
Did Derrick jeter dirty
Your list STINKS!!!
Vlad Jr. 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Says no steroid users but Ortiz made this list somehow
Clemente had a “plus arm”??? Name a player with a better arm? First game I ever went to in 1967 iPittsburgh against Atlanta. Clemente threw out a runner at the plate who had tagged on a deep fly to right. As the ball got closer to the catcher the crowd noise kept getting louder and louder. It was amazing!
derek jeter defensive war is not good he is known for mr.october which big papi was to probably the most clutch player is recent memory i say he is a legend
Hank Aaron is the home run king. Lemme tell you why. Barry Bonds took steroids and Hank Aaron never cheated.
Ozzie Smith? He is the best defensive shortstop this game has ever seen plus he could hit for contact with a league average. Horrible pick
Where is randy Johnson 🤣
Where is George Sisler?
Willie McCovey the most under-rated GREAT player in history
Bonds has more homers than Kaline and Gwynn put together
Griffey is NOT in the top 5 ever
How about Eddie Mathews?
Aaron isnt better than Bonds or Mays
i mean not saying david ortiz or adgar martinez are legendary however if ur going to make the defense argument ted Williams was a terrible defender, same with babe ruth, jimmie foxx and others so does that mean they should be moved to legendary I don't think so but it seems that where your logic might lay
ichiro is leagues better than rickey henderson
Garbage list from a garbage person.
Roberto Clemente definitely a goat 🐐
Did anyone see no steroid players 😂
imo Mike Trout, Ken Griffy Jr, Willie Mays, Lou Gerig, Hank Arron, Ted Williams, Micky Mantel. Babe Ruth and Joe Demogio are best players of all time.
Banks was a SS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
What is fluffy smoking?
It was all good until Mike Trout
Not a goat, at least not now
Any list that doesn't put Babe Ruth at number one if complete bs.
My top 5:
Yeah. I'd say
1. Babe Ruth
2. Ted Williams
3. Willie Mays
4. Hank Aaron
5. Barry Bonds
Darryl strawberry and Jim Thome cheated
Yes sir hank Aron is a goat and Barry bonds did substins
Trash list
hank aaron home run king
hank aaron still the home run king
Wat about mariano rivera greatest closer ever in my opinion 5 time ws champion
After Mickey Mantel, the best player is going to be is Mike Trout.
Best player ever was Mickey Mantel. He could run, bat for average, bat for Home Run, decent arm, and decent defense. He could run and stole bases, even playing with his knees wrap around all time.