Dan Szymborski FanGraphs Chat – 8/4/22

Dan Szymborski: Hi there folks!

Dan Szymborski: And perhaps some bots.

Dan Szymborski: Or cats or alien lifeforms.

Dan Szymborski: However in all probability folks.

Wiz: Is there a group arrange higher than the Os over the subsequent decade? I imply, WOW

Dan Szymborski: I imply, O’s gained’t have Dodgers cash however the ought to have a pleasant remainder of 2020s!

Wiz: Will we see Gunnar Henderson this 12 months? Odor for Henderson looks as if one of many clearest methods so as to add like a win and a half the remainder of the way in which.

Dan Szymborski: I believe no since he’s not on the 40-man

Dan Szymborski: I don’t know if the O’s essentially wish to add him proper now.

Dan Szymborski: (to not point out the standard service time video games)

Huge Al: Mike Elias acknowledged that this off season the Orioles will likely be rather more keen to spend on FA’s, do you might have any concept who may match? I assume some arms.

Dan Szymborski: I can see the O’s taking a look at arms

Dan Szymborski: Although the market isn’t *nice*

Dan Szymborski: ZiPS had Musgrove much better than the remainder of the possible FAs

Dan Szymborski: (You’ll be able to see that in Musgrove ZiPS piece)

Dan Szymborski: However I can see them selecting up some inning-eaters

Dan Szymborski: Observe that I’m anticipated DeGrom to truly take the choice given his harm

Dan Szymborski: deGrom

Dan Szymborski: However I may see midrange pitcher choices like Eovaldi or Taillon

Tacoby Bellsbury: Should you had been a GM who obtained to decide on which rebuild you’re inheriting between the Nats, Reds or A’s, which might you choose and why? (Baseball causes solely — the “chili” vs. proximity to your own home ought to make Cincinnati a wash.)

Dan Szymborski: Dangit, can’t use driving distance?

Dan Szymborski: Then in all probability DC, as a result of there I can *envision* the group spending cash once more

Dan Szymborski: I imply, they *did* provide Soto greater than $400 million

Bob: Why do you assume Willson Contreras remains to be a Cub?

Dan Szymborski: I believe they attempt to lengthen him

HornsUp: I can defend the Cubs not buying and selling Contreras or Happ if they didn’t just like the presents, however shouldn’t they’ve been completely happy to get a Circuit Metropolis reward card for Smyly?

Dan Szymborski: Perhaps they didn’t get a present card!

Dan Szymborski: Happ I can perceive since Happ isn’t a FA

Jason N: That Brandon Drury pickup was HUGE

Dan Szymborski: I wouldn’t go that far, however he’s helpful

Oakland Ass: Hey White Sox did one thing on the deadline — not firing Sleepy Eyes LaRussa

Dan Szymborski: I imply, Reinsdorf didn’t promote

Anon21: Converse consolation to me, Dan. Why has Ronald Acuña’s 5-year projection collapsed between final 12 months’s commerce worth checklist and this 12 months’s? Is it principally enjoying time (which is inherently extra unsure)?

Dan Szymborski: Harm not totally baked in till return and his play is WAY down total

Oakland Ass: Can Angels do something in subsequent 2-3 years to develop into good?

Dan Szymborski: Nothing sensible, no

asnbrv: How does ZiPS have any concept how good a fielder is that hasnt had any mlb enjoying time?

Dan Szymborski: I’ve a complete zone-esque minor league system

Dan Szymborski: I’ve the situation knowledge for each ball hit in each minor league recreation going again to 2008

Dan Szymborski: and a probabilistic measure for each ball hit

Dan Szymborski: Sorry, was in search of a graphic

Dan Szymborski: For instance, listed here are grounder charges by vector

Dan Szymborski:

Perry Minasian: Do I commerce Ohtani this offseason? And if that’s the case, what % of the Soto return ought to I anticipate to get?

Dan Szymborski: No, becuase you’d in all probability solely get half.

Biscuit: Assume Barrero can ultimately impression a significant league roster? That Ok fee seems fairly scary.

Dan Szymborski: I’m more and more pessimistic. His plate self-discipline numbers have collapsed within the minors this 12 months, together with every part else

Dansby SwanSong: I nonetheless don’t perceive why the Yankees traded Montgomery for an incredible defensive CFer who’s on the IL with plantar fasciitis.  Please provide your take.

Dan Szymborski: He must be again. Playing cards are being cautious.

Oakland Ass: Which fan base ought to have much less hope: Rockies or Royals?

Dan Szymborski: Rockies

Dan Szymborski: The Royals have a craptacular plan that wants every part to go proper, however typically they land on free parking

Dan Szymborski: And once they’re good, they’ve the understanding to reinforce that

Dan Szymborski: when the royals had their second, they DID make trades so as to add expertise

Dan Szymborski: The Rockies simply shuffle alongside randomly.

Dan Szymborski: Gimme a crappy plan mixed with boldness than no plan mixed with indolence

KIDZERO: Very long time Rockies fan who is completely disillusioned by Rockies entrance workplace.  Iglesias, Colome, Kuhl, Estevez all quickly to be free brokers, however not moved for any future gamers…put me out of my distress!

Dan Szymborski: I’m not allowed to homicide folks, I feel.

Dan Szymborski: However right here’s my assortment of Hearthstone-Rockies pictures.

Dan Szymborski:

Dan Szymborski:

Dan Szymborski:

Dan Szymborski:

Dan Szymborski:

Dan Szymborski: For individuals who don’t get the final reference, the Rockies held a pizza occasion on the commerce deadline as an alternative of doing something

James: Persons are sleeping on Profar this season, dude’s rockin a 126 wRC+ and projected to complete with ~3.7 fWAR. He’s in all probability opting out this winter, proper?

Dan Szymborski: I feel it’s possible

Dan Szymborski: He can in all probability beat 1/7.5 with a ten mutual possibility, which is what he has if he doesn’t decide out

Oakland Ass: Let’s play make imagine — Hosmer opts out. How a lot does he get as a free agent?

Dan Szymborski: ZiPS would provide him one-year, $2.3 million.

Oakland Ass: I get the A’s transferring however is Las Vegas actually marketplace for baseball or simply a straightforward mark to get stadium funding?

Dan Szymborski: Latter

M’s Fan: Who may/ought to the M’s goal within the offseason so as to add a bat?  The farm is fairly gutted to make a commerce now.

Dan Szymborski: This isnt one of many extra thrilling FA years

Dan Szymborski: Abreu as DH can be enjoyable

Dan Szymborski: Should you can settle who performs the place with none disasters, Swanson or, assuming opt-out occurs, Bogaerts

Dan Szymborski: (I’d attempt to transfer JP to 2B for Swanson, not for Bogaerts, so who is aware of who would get pissed)

Didace: What group has a greater file in 2025 – Padres or Nationals? (Please say Nationals, I would like to be ok with this case.)

Dan Szymborski: Nationals BUT YOU MADE ME

Dan Szymborski: It’s actually arduous to inform with a lot uncertainty

Dan Szymborski: The Padres may go doomsday clock for finish of 2024

Rob: Rutschman is already prime 10 in catcher WAR in half the video games however would love greater than 5 homers in 50+ video games!

Dan Szymborski: DONT BE GREEDY

JasonM: Out of your Article on Aug 2nd “Padres Push In All Their Chips, Agree to Deal for Juan Soto and Josh Bell” you acknowledged that “(12 months-by-year projections for Wooden and Susana are sadly past ZiPS’ scope at this stage of their careers.)”  What’s the tipping level the place ZiPS is ready to do year-by-year projections on gamers? Wooden has solely has a pair hundred PAs at low-A up to now, is it a matter of simply having a bigger pattern at low-A (or beneath) or would he must have performed at A+? or AA?

Dan Szymborski: It’s principally the place I’m comfy

Dan Szymborski: I don’t like projecting hitters till a full season of excessive A and pitchers till they’ve not less than SOME AA time

Dan Szymborski: not less than, not sufficient to do 12 months by 12 months readouts

Dan Szymborski: as a result of the volatility is MASSIVE for these guys

Dan Szymborski: Simply comfy sufficient with the imply WAR totals for the prospect rankings

John: How vast do you imagine the hole is between the highest and backside groups in terms of growing and making use of analytical instruments and fashions?

Dan Szymborski: Actually smaller than 20 years in the past

Dan Szymborski: A foul entrance workplace now — let’s say the Royals — can be within the prime tier in 1995

Dan Szymborski: Rockies are poorly run regardless of the period

Frank Thomas the Tank Engine: Did the Dodgers make a mistake in not including one other excessive leverage reliever?

Dan Szymborski: I feel it’s a risk

Fanny: Hi there Dan, it looks as if some gamers had been simply in the proper place on the proper time, comparable to Jose Altuve and the way he ended up getting signed by the Astros. Who do you assume one of the best participant(s) is who by no means had the chance? Not somebody like Grady Sizemore for instance, who was derailed by accidents; and never somebody who was a hyped prospect however then simply by no means produced, like Mark Appel (although he presently he has 1.74 ERA with the Phillies?!?). However somebody who appeared like they may have been actually good however simply by no means obtained the possibility to both get referred to as up or get a full-time job. Anybody come to thoughts?

Dan Szymborski: All time? That’s arduous, it is dependent upon what you contemplate an excessive amount of of a chance.

Dan Szymborski: Roberto Petagine by no means actually obtained constant playign time

Dan Szymborski: Greg LaRocca had a a lot smaller window

Dan Szymborski: Scott McClain needs to be on that checklist

Dan Szymborski: Karl Pagel

Dan Szymborski: Brian Dopirak

Dan Szymborski: sorry, simply pondering of names right here

Cat Latos: What do my cat associates do?

Dan Szymborski: Final I noticed them, Constantine was sitting on the kitchen counter as a result of he was getting hungry, Cassiopeia was on a blanket in a visitor bed room, and Mercutio was bullying Justinian over the fishing pole that may be a lengthy fluffy yellow measuring tape with a bell on the finish

Frank Thomas the Tank Engine: The Rays can be in hassle for doing little on the deadline if not for the Pink Sox, White Sox, and Guardians doing (web) nothing to assist themselves proper?

Dan Szymborski: Yeah, it wasn’t essentially the most thrilling deadline for the Rays

Romorr: Contemplating the return the Reds obtained fir Mahle, would you might have favored to have seen Mike Elias beat that? Underneath management for subsequent 12 months as effectively made him enticing in my eyes.

Dan Szymborski: Meh

Dan Szymborski: I’d reasonably the O’s hand over cash in FA than prospects

Large Gonzales: How do you view Bloom as a GM up to now? I assumed this may be extra of a retool whereas rebuilding the farm system, however the returns on the Betts commerce are beneath cromulent, the Renfroe swap is a meh, and the “large” cash Story signing isn’t trying too scorching. Is that this a case the place it’s 5 years in earlier than he’s completed shedding all of the earlier contracts/gamers? If Devers doesn’t get prolonged, it’s a tricky tablet to swallow watching the quantity of younger expertise that’s left over the previous couple years.

Dan Szymborski: I feel it’s arduous to say up to now; I feel he’s additionally underneath a variety of possession constraints

Dan Szymborski: name it an incompelte

Dan Szymborski: For instance, I’ve religion foundation to imagine that possession insisted on a participant who may contribute now for Betts

Romorr: With simply 93 video games above A+ for Gunnar, are you comfy with the service time assetments? For me, I can type of see either side to this.

Dan Szymborski: Right here’s what it comes all the way down to for me

Dan Szymborski:

1. What’s he going to do towards AAA pitchers that he isn’t already to be extra prepared?
2. Is he higher than who he would substitute?

Dan Szymborski: If the reply is shrug and sure, then it’s service time

Dan Szymborski: He’s a 21-year-old who can play shortstop and a .939 OPS at AAA. What precise talent will he develop AAA now exterior of merely beating the pitchers up much more?

Dan Szymborski: That’s the query one has to reply

Dan Szymborski: I’m not essentially saying YOU must reply it

Dan: What’s your opinion on the Ruf commerce? Have seen reactions starting from what are the Mets doing to this commerce isn’t nice for both group

Dan Szymborski: I feel it’s high-quality

Dan Szymborski: Mets wish to win now and now they’ve a platoon of huge grownup son and enormous grownup uncle

Dan Szymborski: If Davis hits higher, he can simply be a beginning DH subsequent 12 months for Giants perhaps

Dan Szymborski: and whereas three prospects went to Giants, it’s not like these had been PROSPECTS

City Shocker’s Jockstrap: Vital simulation request: Are you able to run a WWE tag group of Juan Soto and Scott Boras vs. the Lerner household?

Dan Szymborski: I may. I have already got Juan Soto helpful!

Dan Szymborski:

Dan Szymborski: Must make him a brand new uni in fact

Dan Szymborski: Gratuitous

Dan Szymborski:

Joelskil: Why are sunsets prettier than sunrises?

Dan Szymborski: Since you’re in all probability not going to work after the previous

Paul: Ideas on the Brewers’ DFAing Lamet?

Dan Szymborski: I’m stunned that they did it so shortly

Nolan: deGrom says he wont take the choice tho, and if continues to appear like deGrom I don’t see how he’s not gonna get a greater deal

Dan Szymborski: Oh, I missed that he mentioned that!

JC: Clint Frazier’s web page is lacking.

Dan Szymborski: He began going by his center title, Jackson, just a few months in the past

Dealing with Your Outdated Staff: I’ve at all times been inquisitive about instances of gamers dealing with their outdated group for the primary time.  For instance, Jordan Montgomery’s first STL begin is towards NYY this weekend.  In instances like that, does both group acquire an inherent benefit over the opposite?  Does Montgomery have really feel for what his former teammates can’t hit so he can inform his new rotation-mates?  Do Yankee catchers inform different Yankee hitters what Montgomery likes to throw in sure conditions?

Dan Szymborski: Truthfully, I’ve by no means really researched that individual situation

Dan Szymborski: It could be enjoyable to take a look at although

Unhappy Nats Fan: Why do the Braves regularly signal their gamers to relative bargains?! IT’S NOT FAIR! I’m not crying you’re!

Dan Szymborski: No less than this was a good deal!

Dan Szymborski: That Albies deal…

Visitor: Christian Encarnacion-Strand not a lot of a prospect per the scouting report, however he has completed nothing however hit. Is a scouting replace on the way in which?

Dan Szymborski: There was a midseason one!

Dan Szymborski: He’ll definitely get a ZiPS this 12 months

Visitor: when Zips runs extension analyses, does it use a sliding scale of {dollars} per warfare or is it a 1:1 ratio? For instance, a participant with a excessive likelihood of offering lower than one WAR would have worth nearer to substitute stage for these seasons however a a lot larger $ per WAR for seasons of three+ projected WAR?

Dan Szymborski: The factor is that after the primary win, $/win is *nonetheless* sorta working

Dan Szymborski: the factor is, it ALWAYS ought to have been non-linear

Dan Szymborski: but it surely’s at all times acted linear, roughly

Dan Szymborski: that appears to be altering, most for mediocre gamers

TKDC: The Nats would have been ecstatic if Soto would have agreed to that underneath market deal, however don’t you assume it was designed to shift blame? “Hey, we tried?” $440 million appears extra acceptable for 10 years, not 15. If Soto turned *that* down, then they may legitimately say they tried.

Dan Szymborski: They in all probability ought to have simply supplied 10 as a result of years 11-15 for ANYONE is basically low worth due to uncertainty

Dan Szymborski: I’m undecided you provide half-a-billion bucks for PR

Cito: The place can followers discover public defensive metrics for Minor Leaguers past the easy assists, errors, performs, and many others? I do know of Clay Davenport’s website, however any others?

Dan Szymborski: It’s really type of arduous

Dan Szymborski: there isn’t a lot on the market

Juan Soto: How lengthy had been organizations utilizing deeper analytics earlier than basic baseball fandom realized how essential that they had develop into?

Dan Szymborski: Not that lengthy actually

Dan Szymborski: you return to the 80s, whiel there have been at all times a pair numbers guys hanging round

Dan Szymborski: like Eddie Epstein

Dan Szymborski: however the analytics *had been* rudimentary

Dan Szymborski: and actually, the 90s sabermetric group was forward of groups

Dan Szymborski: on the time

Dan Szymborski: Moneyball actually *did* assist to extra shortly modernize entrance workplaces than they might have in any other case

Visitor: does Rodon decide out this off season, if that’s the case, are Cardinals, Rangers…anybody else prime locations?

Dan Szymborski: I feel he does, however I kinda anticipate the Giants to drop an enormous extension provide earlier than finish of season

Unhappy Nats Fan: To be truthful–half the Soto return remains to be vital. That’s how large it was.

Dan Szymborski: However I feel the Angels have the concept Ohtani is AS worthwhile

Dan Szymborski: He’s not. You get half the time

Visitor: Does MJ Melendez provide extra worth as an OF or catcher?

Dan Szymborski: c

Service Time Impingement Syndrome: Do you might have a tackle what’s occurring with Luis Robert and why the White Sox feedback on the scenario are so convoluted? Is it simply HIPAA compliance? Or one thing extra?

Dan Szymborski: The issue is that MLB’s CBA, finally verify, solely permits group’s to reveal *employment-related* accidents

Dan Szymborski: so there’s this bizarre kabuki the place they’ll’t actually SAY {that a} participant is out with COVID or one thing except the participant’s cool with it

Cito: Ronny Mauricio ranked #17 in your pre-season ZiPS 100. How a lot do you anticipate him to fall with the poor stroll fee and call points this season?

Dan Szymborski: a bunch

Will: What are your Qualifying Supply predictions?

Dan Szymborski: I’m not leaking an article I haven’t even considered but! lol

Colton: Do you assume the Cardinals did proper by not together with Carlson in a commerce to get Soto or do you imagine they made a mistake in doing so?

Dan Szymborski: I feel the place the Cardinals had been unwilling was Carlson AND an enormous bundle

Dan Szymborski: The factor is, the Cardinals usually are not gamblers.

Dan Szymborski: They’re the regular, cautious sorts.

Dan Szymborski: The Cardinals calmly and coolly calculate their pot odds

Dan Szymborski: Whereas the Padres see JTs and a pair folks limping in and aggressively elevate

Dick Monfort Windmill Excessive-5: Am I so unsuitable for desperately wanting a Cardinals/Jays WS only for the takes?

Dan Szymborski: No, chaos is at all times an possibility

HornsUp: Extra prone to fall off a cliff after 2024: Padres or Brewers?

Dan Szymborski: Padres actually

Dan Szymborski: Merely primarily based on what they’ve now, not future selections

Dan Szymborski: 4 of their 5 starters are FA this 12 months or subsequent

Dan Szymborski: and some of the possible replacements for one, Gore, is a Nat

Dan Szymborski: On that be aware, I’ve a busy afternoon, so I’ve to maintain this to an hour right now.

Dan Szymborski: Thanks for coming all!

Dan Szymborski: Keep in mind, you may at all times hit me up with stuff on Twitter!

Dan Szymborski: I don’t chew except you’re Murray Chass